Skip to main content

You are here

Fiduciary Rules and Practices

The parties in an excessive fee suit have struck a deal — mere months after the suit was filed. The plan fiduciaries here are Springfield, Massachusetts-based Baystate Health Inc. — and they were sued just last Nov. 17 by participant-plaintiffs Michael Chechile and Sonia Lopez (who were... READ MORE
The Labor Department has weighed in on an excessive fee case on behalf of the participant-plaintiffs — asserting that the district court made a bad call on the burden of proof. The case under appeal involves Home Depot, and a decision last fall by Judge Steven D. Grimberg in the U.S. District... READ MORE
The parties in one of the first university 403(b) excessive fee suits — by participant-plaintiffs represented by the Schlichter law firm — has come to terms on the eve of going to trial.  The suit, filed in August 2016, involved two plans sponsored by the University of Southern California (the... READ MORE
Efforts by proponents to carve out an exemption to a Nevada state fiduciary law for ERISA-covered retirement plan advisors continued this week, with the American Retirement Association (ARA) submitting a letter supporting the exemption.  Nevada State Senate Bill 383 (SB 383), effective July 1,... READ MORE
New year, new duties? A Missouri senator has introduced legislation that would modify the duties of fiduciaries serving public employee retirement systems. Sen. Jill Carter (R-Jasper and Newton) on Jan. 4 introduced the bill, SB 436. It provides that an investment fiduciary would discharge his or... READ MORE
A $4 billion plan has struck a $4 million settlement—and “meaningful prospective relief” — in a suit that challenged the fees it paid itself as recordkeeper for its own plan. Plaintiffs Chris Carrigan, Michael Venti, and Sylvain Yelle (represented by Nichols Kaster PLLP[1] and Garrison, Levin-... READ MORE
A pair of excessive fee suits have been dismissed for failure to state a claim — for now. The separate suits were brought against the fiduciaries of the plans at ThedaCare, Inc. and Prevea Clinic, Inc. In the former, participant-plaintiff Glick had argued (in August 2020) that ThedaCare, Inc. and... READ MORE
Noting that “Plaintiffs fail to plausibly allege the Committee breached its ERISA-imposed fiduciary duty by charging unreasonable recordkeeping fees” — another excessive fee suit has been dismissed. The plaintiffs here — Keith K. Kruchten, Angel D. Muratalla and William Begani — sued on behalf of... READ MORE
Litigator Jerry Schlichter has been sued…for a breach of fiduciary duty. According to a report in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Schlichter (and his firm) has been sued by partner Roger Denton—the third name in St. Louis law firm Schlichter, Bogard and Denton—alleging he’s been cheated out of at... READ MORE
The U.S. Department of Labor has unveiled its much-anticipated final ESG rule that it says will allow “plan fiduciaries to consider climate change and other environmental, social and governance factors when they select retirement investments and exercise shareholder rights, such as proxy voting.”... READ MORE
COVID notwithstanding, the retirement plan industry has seen a record increase in court filings and litigation the past few years — and a recent session at the ASPPA Annual National Conference explored those issues and the underlying causes. The session — led by Kizzy Gaul, Esq, ERISA Attorney at... READ MORE
The parties in another excessive fee suit have come to terms six months after getting the green light to go to trial. In the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin the parties noted that on Sept. 13, 2022, they “…mediated before private mediator Bob Meyer of JAMS, and reached a... READ MORE
“…after meaningful motion practice, discovery, and arm's-length negotiations by experienced counsel, including a private mediation with an experienced neutral mediator,” the parties in an excessive fee suit have come to terms — in less than a year. The parties here — plaintiffs Trudy Clark, Donna... READ MORE
Plaintiffs in one of the first university 403(b) suits to be filed will get their day in court. The suit against Yale University was one of the first to be filed in this area — and by Schlichter Bogard & Denton LLP, the law firm that led the litigation charge against 401(k) plan fees — in... READ MORE
Yet another excessive fee suit has been dismissed for failing to make a “plausible” case. The plaintiff in this case is Kaila Gonzalez, a participant in the Northwell Health 403(b) Plan, who filed suit against Northwell Health, Inc., the Northwell Health 403(b) Plan Committee, and 10 other... READ MORE
Fiduciary defendants are pressing for a reconsideration of their motion to dismiss an excessive fee suit, citing new precedent and its higher threshold to bring suit. The Suit Here participant-plaintiff Glick had argued (in August 2020) that ThedaCare, Inc. and its Board of Directors violated the... READ MORE
The fiduciaries of a relatively small retirement plan have come to relatively smaller terms in an excessive fee suit. First and foremost, the settlement proposed provides $330,000 in the form of a “Settlement Fund.” This litigation was initially commenced on Sept. 3, 2020, alleging that the... READ MORE
The latest excessive fee suit targets “wildly excessive compensation,” an allegedly imprudent stable value offering, and the unmonitored use of “float” income.  More specifically, the participant-plaintiffs of Miami, Florida-based Lennar Corp. are raising issues with the recordkeeping/... READ MORE
Now that the U.S. Senate has confirmed Lisa Gomez to serve as Assistant Secretary for the Department of Labor’s Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA), a lengthy to-do list awaits her attention.   Since the start of the current administration, Ali Khawar has been serving as Acting... READ MORE
A trio of Republican legislators have introduced a bill that would widen the acceptable investment classes in defined contribution plans to, well, pretty much anything—including “digital assets.” The Retirement Savings Modernization Act was just introduced by U.S. Sens. Pat Toomey (R-PA) and Tim... READ MORE

Pages